When it comes to the college application process, it seems more — more extracurriculars, more teacher recommendations, more AP and honors classes — is better. So it stands to reason that the more colleges you apply to, the more successful you’ll be at getting accepted, right? Not exactly.

While it’s smart to have a selection of schools divided into reaches, goals and probable acceptances on your application list, there’s a point at which it becomes unnecessarily expensive, time-consuming, stressful and a possible hindrance to your chances of admission. Unfortunately, a magic number of colleges to apply to doesn’t exist, but these guardrails can help inform your process.

The Numbers

While it may seem like everyone else in your senior class is dropping a stack of apps 20 deep, double digits are not the norm. In fact, according to a recently published study from the National Center for Educational Statistics, the average number of college applications is just under three per student. That said, if you have your sights set on competitive schools, adding a few more to the mix is a smart idea.

“I’d rather you truly be excited about everywhere you are applying.”

“I advocate coming up with a quality list of about 6 to 12 schools, because schools want to see that you’ve actually done your research and know about the institution,” says Danny Ruderman, a college admissions counselor and author of Top 100 Answers to Your College Admissions Questions. “Even if the school accepts the Common Application, many have supplemental application materials that include short answers about why you want to go to that particular school. If you have too many on your list, your answer will likely sound vague, and it won’t give the college incentive to accept you. I’d rather you truly be excited about everywhere you are applying.”

Maia Goita, 19, a sophomore at Baruch College, agrees. “I applied to six schools and I think it was the right call for me,” she says. “I didn’t want to apply to more since all required additional essays, and I didn’t want to spread myself too thin and produce writing that was anything less than my best.”

The Right Mix

“While I never give a specific number, I’m all about making sure students have a healthy mix of schools on their list,” says Greg Kaplan, a college admissions strategist and author of Earning Admission: Real Strategies for Getting into a Highly Selective College. “That includes two or three safety schools, which I help students choose by looking at data. For example, if a school accepts 40 percent of applicants, and a student’s GPA and test scores would likely put them in the top 25 percent of potential applicants to that school — that would be considered a safety.” Meanwhile, a target school would be one where your student profile — including GPA and test scores — fits well within the median range or 50th percentile of students accepted the year prior. And a reach is a school where your scores may fall more than a hair below those of the average accepted student last year.

Often, students end up with lists that are too top heavy, says Bari Meltzer Norman, owner of Expert Admissions, a college admissions counseling service based in New York City. “There’s a misconception that applying to reach schools is like entering a lottery, and applying to eight increases your chances of getting into one,” she explains. “It doesn’t work that way. Each is its own contest, and it’s better to focus more heavily on target schools you have a better likelihood of getting into.” These schools are ones that admit students with GPAs, test scores and interests in line with yours and where you can genuinely see yourself.

Whether you’re applying to 3 schools or 15, experts agree that what matters most is feeling passionate and excited about all the institutions you apply to.

The Edit

“I did a lot of research in my sophomore and junior years and knew I wanted to go to a private college on the West Coast, preferably a Christian one,” says Delaney Clark, 20, a junior at Gonzaga University in Spokane, WA. “I applied to 10 schools, all in Washington and California, and got into 9. But looking back, I almost feel like it was too many. I was grateful I had choices, but I also felt overwhelmed.”

In general, it’s a good idea to winnow down your list by the summer after your junior year, at which point you’ll have had a chance to visit schools (or at least spend a few hours on their websites). You should be able to confidently subdivide your list into:

  • one or two reach schools
  • three to five target schools
  • two or three safety schools

And even if you’re pretty confident about which school you want to go to — say, you’re planning on attending a state school that automatically accepts in-state residents with a certain GPA or test scores — it may still be worth your time to look around and consider adding a few more options, just in case you change your mind.

“I had always thought I wanted to pursue cosmetology, and it wasn’t until late in my senior year of high school that I realized I even wanted to go to a four-year college,” says Madeleine Page, 21, a senior at Texas State University. “At that point, because I was so late in the game, I only applied to one school, but looking back, I wish I had chosen at least three.”

Remember: You Have to Choose One

Whether you’re applying to 3 schools or 15, experts agree that what matters most is feeling passionate and excited about all the institutions you apply to. “I’ve seen students who just want to get as many acceptances as possible,” says Rhea Watson, a scholarship coach for My Scholarship Solutions, a scholarship counseling firm in Las Vegas. “That’s fine, but remember, you can only choose one [four year] college, and too many acceptances can make the final decision more complicated than it has to be.” So relax (as much as possible) and realize that if you have a strong list and a strong application, quality is far more important than quantity.